Design Ethics: Superpower of Designers
December, 2020
Last month, we hosted our first Twin-City Service Design Drinks Singapore x Berlin on the topic of Design Ethics, to a global audience of 187 participants.
In case you missed the event, watch the edited video here:
If you’d just like a brief summary, here are the key points:
What is Design Ethics?
Ethics | ˈɛθɪks |
moral principles that govern a person's behaviour or the conducting of an activity
the moral correctness of specified conduct
Ethics is, in its essence, a sense of right and wrong. It can be relative to the culture it exists in, and our perspective is often shaped by the communities which we identify with. Our perspectives however, can change over time, and what we’ve perceived as acceptable can shift when we magnify it through a more critical lens.
What superpower do designers have?
The role of a designer has constantly been evolving while impacting the way we live, perceive and behave. Ever more so with the introduction of technology, that impact has increased ten fold.
As seen in the film The Social Dilemma, those in charge of designing our day-to-day behaviours through tech products or social media platforms have been instrumental in creating positive societal change, but these platforms have also caused problematic social, political and cultural consequences. These designers have ‘superpowers’, but the power of a ‘superpower’ lies in why and how we use it.
How do we navigate the complexities of ethics in decision making?
Although most of us would like to imagine ourselves as empathetic, human-centric, and problem solvers who hold ethics in high regard, ethics is often regarded as a philosophical and subjective discussion, where it becomes an afterthought rather than a skill which we actively practice and prioritise.
Our relationship with ethics is quite a complicated one whenever ethics emerge in our everyday decisions.
When designing technology, the mechanics that shape behaviour are vital for the growth of organisations.
A few tips from our speakers to consider when designing:
Define ethical guidelines before shaping behaviours, so we are mindful of ethical considerations when designing technology.
Focus on the plurality of humans (e.g. non-users, communities, democracies and nations), and not just the plurality of end-users, in order to avoid oversight as design impacts more than just the user.
Start thinking of how design can affect the wider map of stakeholders not just now, but in the times to come so we can be adept in spotting ethical harms before they happen.
Poll Results
During our event, we conducted 5 short polls in order to gain an understanding of how our participants felt towards design ethics.
The results reveal that although many of us find design ethics necessary to be on the table for discussion, there is still much room for thought to develop around design ethics and for it to grow as a key consideration during our design process.
Here is a quick summary of the poll results:
Bringing design ethics onto the table may lead to complex discussions, and it is our hope that we actively continue this conversation and keep this dialogue ongoing as a community - in our workplaces, our homes, and our social circles - so that we can progressively take strides in designing for ethics.
To stay up to date with our future events, do follow SDD Singapore on LinkedIn and SDD Berlin on Insta, Facebook and LinkedIn. We look forward to seeing you all once again!
Links shared during the event that you might find useful:
Further Reading (web resources)
A Designer’s Code of Ethics, article by Mike Monteiro: https://bit.ly/3fQqII9
A Fool with a Tool is still a Fool, closing keynote by Clive K. Lavery at ToolFest Berlin 2019: https://bit.ly/35CWF2V
Design Ettiquette: A Case for Ethics as a Design Skill, thesis by Ziqq Rafit: https://bit.ly/2J3dBY5
Ethical Growth Hacking, presentation by Sera Tajima: https://bit.ly/36azNYT
Unintended Consequences, by Rob Norton: https://bit.ly/2V9cuZ3
Web Content Accessibility Guidelines, by W3C Web Accessibility Initiative (WAI): https://bit.ly/37d293T
Toolkits
Ethical Explorer, tools to help navigate the future impact of today’s technology: https://ethicalexplorer.org/
Books
Design for Cognitive Bias, by David Dylan Thomas: https://bit.ly/39gc6QZ
Design Justice: Community-Led Practices to Build the Worlds We Need, by Sasha Costanza-Chock: https://amzn.to/3q4i9hg
Future Ethics, by Cennydd Bowles: https://bit.ly/3q4Moot
Moralizing Technology: Understanding and Designing the Morality of Things, by Peter-Paul Verbeek: https://amzn.to/3fCEY77
Technology and the Virtues, by Shannon Vallor: https://bit.ly/37aaJAt
The Ethical Design Handbook, by Trine Falbe, Martin Michael Frederiksen & Kim Andersen: https://ethicaldesignhandbook.com/
Communities
A11y Peru, a community for digital accessibility: https://bit.ly/2VdqK2V
Parents that UX, by Clive K. Lavery: https://bit.ly/3mbvd1X
The Purpose Fellowship, by tbd* and The Arc: https://bit.ly/2V6Av35
UX Book Club Berlin, by Clive K. Lavery: https://bit.ly/3q4PoBf
Social Good
Betterplace.org, the largest German donation platform: https://www.betterplace.org/de
ReDI School of Digital Integration, a non-profit digital school for tech-interested locals and newcomers in Germany: https://de.redi-school.org/berlin
Spice Program, an open source and social impact program sponsored by Futurice: https://spiceprogram.org/